Confronting postcolonial theory a response to critics, the journal of world systems research, winter 2014, volume 20. Vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital is misleadingly framed as a critique of postcolonial theory, but this is either false advertising or willful ignorance of the. Despite its title, vivek chibber s book is not about postcolonial theory, but rather subaltern studies, a series of volumes principally concerned with indian history that appeared between 1982 and 2008. End of the commodity supercycle, or return of neoliberalism. When did you first become interested in writing a critique of it. Some scholars have begun to question the usefulness of the concept postcolonial theory. Focusing on the hugely popular subaltern studies project, chibber carefully examines this projects core arguments about the specificity of the global south and the deficiencies. In this devastating critique, mounted on behalf of the radical enlightenment tradition, vivek chibber offers the most comprehensive response yet to postcolonial theory. Despite its title, vivek chibbers book is not about postcolonial theory, but rather subaltern studies, a series of volumes principally concerned with indian history that appeared between 1982 and 2008. In this devastating critique, mounted on behalf of the radical enlightenment tradition, vivek chibber offers the most comprehensive response yet to. The key concepts is fully updated and crossreferenced throughout. Over the past two decades there has been a steady move away from systematic class analysis of state strategies toward statecentric approaches. A new volume, the debate on postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, captures this sometimes ornery debate.
Pdf a critique of vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital by vivek. Colonialism and postcolonialism university of oxford. Vivek chibber crushes with a blow meant to help rather than harm.
The debate on postcolonial theory and the specter of. Since its publication in 20, vivek chibbers book postcolonial theory and the specter of capital ptsc has generated a lot of scholarly discussion. Vivek chibber curriculum vitae february 2015 sociology. Vivek chibbers new book, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, represents a wideranging challenge to many of the core tenets of postcolonial theory. Program in anthropology invites you to attend our fall 20 colloquia. Postcolonial studies and the specter of misplaced polemics. With postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, vivek chibber challenges the post marxist theories of a major postcolonial historical research project known as subaltern studies. Many postcolonial writers write in english and focus on common themes such as the struggle for independence, emigration, national. Vivek chibber is professor of sociology at the department of sociology, new york university. Indian marxist scholar vivek chibber has critiqued some foundational logics of postcolonial theory in his book postcolonial theory and the specter of capital. Chibber is the author of two books, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital verso, 20 and locked in place. The aim of new york university sociology professor vivek chibbers latest book postcolonial theory and the specter. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital is not only a well reasoned and researched critique of what makes up for a lot of fashionable nonsense in academia, but ought to serve as a model for its clarity and consideration. One can posit phases in post colonial theory, moving across time from the post war reaction against colonial rule in the fifties and the sixties, albert memmi 1920, aime cesaire 192008, and frantz fanon 19251962, to name a few writers, the shift towards an analysis of culture through the lens of representation.
Statebuilding and late industrialization in india, which won the barrington moore, jr. Feb 06, 2016 postcolonial theory and the specter of capital. With consummate ease loomba maps the field, unravels the many strands of the debate and provides a considered critique. What are some of the core propositions of postcolonial theory. The debate on postcolonial theory and the specter of capital. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital is a mustread book for students of comparative politics and social theory.
Vivek chibber is an american academic, social theorist, editor, and professor of sociology at new york university, who has published widely on development disambiguation needed, social theory, and politics. Ptsc primarily aims to uncover the conceptual and empirical flaws within subaltern studies, an important strand of. He then develops a theory of the structural conditions that can account for the different reactions of indian and korean capitalists as rational responses to the distinct development models adopted in each country. In the meantime, i try to keep up with the scholarly commentary on chibbers book, including gayatri chakravorty spivaks blistering. Vivek chibber presents a forceful challenge to the subaltern studies school and to postcolonial theory more broadly. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital wikipedia. The fate of labor in postcolonial india paper presented at conference on rethinking class.
Vivek chibber is stumped by his desire to correct everybodythe. Project muse postcolonial theory and the specter of. Leading thinkers critiques of awardwinning postcolonial theory, as well as the authors responses and reformulations vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter of capital was hailed on publication as without any doubt a bomb, and the most substantive effort to dismantle the field through historical reasoning published to date. Vivek chibber postcolonial theory and the specter of capital. As a loosely affiliated group, the ssg just one branch of the rather nebulous category of postcolonial theory has, according to chibber, committed the crime of abetting the fragmentation of the radical left into isolated cabals of pet political projects by aiming to supplant. Vivek chibber postcolonial theory and the specter of. Vivek chibber, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, new york, verso, 20, isbn 9781844679775 hbk, isbn 9781844679768 pbk, 320 pp penny for the old guy.
The recent accusation by vivek chibber that postcolonialism is antienlightenment repeats this gesture. Vivek chibber author of postcolonial theory and the specter. Focusing on the hugely popular subaltern studies project, chibber shows that its foundational arguments are based on a series of analytical and historical misapprehensions. Apr 07, 2014 gayatri chakravorty spivak i have plans to get around to vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter of capital at some point as well as ranajit guhas dominance without hegemony, one of chibbers chief targets. Postcolonial theory and really existing capitalism. Vivek chibber s locked in place is a brilliant, benchmark study of the developmental state and its dilemmas. Jun 21, 2014 vivek chibber, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, london and new york. To do so involved three distinct tasks first, to distill from the key writings what the projects. Review of vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the. Vivek chibber, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, new york, verso, 20, isbn 9781844679775 hbk, isbn 9781844679768 pbk, 320 pp.
Arguing with great clarity, chibber raises fundamental objections to their ideas about capitalism, power, and agency, and presents an alternative account of these ideas. Review of vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter. Bill ashcroft teaches at the university of hong kong and the university of nsw, gareth grif. His book postcolonial theory and the specter of capital 20 can be read as yet another attack on postcolonial theory in the defense of marxism, along the lines mounted by aijaz ahmad 1992, arif dirlik 1994, san juan, jr. Vivek chibber is professor of sociology at new york university and the author of postcolonial theory and the specter of capital and locked in place. Leckey1 postcolonial scholarship is a comparatively recent branch of study in academia, yet the extent to which it is infiltrating various social theories across numerous academic disciplines necessitates its inclusion in the mainstream of analysis of social phenomena goss 1996. Statebuilding and late industrialization in india princeton, 2003. With postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, vivek chibber challenges the postmarxist theories of a major postcolonial historical research project known as subaltern studies. Vivek chibber is the author of postcolonial theory and the specter of capital 4. The graduate center, the city university of new york established in 1961, the graduate center of the city university of new york cuny is devoted primarily to doctoral studies and awards most of cunys doctoral degrees. This symposium puts together five commentaries on the specter of capital from diverse disciplinary perspectives, together with chibber s response. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital is a 20 book by the indian sociologist and new york university professor vivek chibber coming from the radical enlightenment tradition, this book is a critique of postcolonial theory. Vivek chibber, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, 20.
Vivek chibber has written a stunning critique of postcolonial theory as represented by the subaltern studies school. Vivek chibber author of postcolonial theory and the. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital by vivek chibber. Postcolonialism is a critical theory analysis of the history, culture, literature, and discourse of european imperial power. In his postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, vivek chibber recognises that the truly innovative dimension of subaltern studies, then, was to marry popular history to the analysis of colonial and postcolonial capitalism 6. Like the idea of the scottish fourstages theory, a theory with which it would appear to have little in common, the very concept of postcolonialism seems to rely on a progressive understanding of history mcclintock 1992. Pdf riview symposium on vivek chibbers post colonial.
With additional further reading this book has everything necessary for students and anyone keen to learn more about this fascinating subject. Saids profound commitment to humanism, universal rights, secularism and liberalism on the one hand, and postcolonial theorys quite explicit disavowal of, or at least its skepticism toward, those very. The name postcolonialism is modeled on postmodernism, with which it. Colonialism and postcolonialism daniel butt, university of bristol forthcoming in hugh lafollette ed.
Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital vivek. Vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital george steinmetz forthcoming in journal of world system research 2014 postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital is an important book on a topic of major. An introduction to postcolonialism, postcolonial theory and. It immediately unleashed one of the most important recent debates in social theory, ranging across the. Vivek chibber s postcolonial theory and the specter of capital is a superb and devastating critique of postcolonial studies postmodernism applied to the global south and an equally brilliant defense of the radical enlightenment tradition. Ranajit guha, dipesh chakrabarty, and partha chatterjee. Colonial discourse and post colonial theory a reader pdf. Postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital journal of. Colonialism postcolonialism download pdfepub ebook.
Feb 12, 20 vivek chibber crushes with a blow meant to help rather than harm. Vivek chibber, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, london and new york. Focusing particularly on the strain of postcolonial theory known as subaltern studies, chibber makes a strong case for why we can and must conceptualize the nonwestern world. Vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter of capital was hailed on publication as without any doubt a bomb, and the most substantive effort to dismantle the field through historical reasoning published to date. In this devastating critique, vivek chibber offers the most comprehensive response yet to postcolonial theory mounted on behalf of the radical enlightenment tradition. Feb 25, 2014 in this devastating critique, mounted on behalf of the radical enlightenment tradition, vivek chibber offers the most comprehensive response yet to postcolonial theory.
He has contributed to, among others, the socialist register. Marxism, postcolonial studies, and the tasks of radical theory. Postcolonial theory has become enormously influential as a framework for understanding the global south. Includes introduction by hofung hung, essays by david pedersen, george steinmetz, bruce cummings, michael schwartz, william h. Dec 08, 2016 vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter of capital was hailed on publication as without any doubt a bomb, and the most substantive effort to dismantle the field through historical reasoning published to date. An internationally recognized center for advanced studies and a national model for public doctoral education, the graduate center offers more than thirty doctoral programs in. Vivek chibber is professor of sociology at new york university.
This symposium puts together five commentaries on the specter of capital from diverse disciplinary perspectives, together with chibbers response. However, in highlighting the distinctiveness of the postcolonial world, postcolonial theorists are charged with denying the universal valid. C415a, followed by receptions in the brockway room rm. Rosie warren is assistant editor at verso books, and editorinchief of the journal salvage.
Unless otherwise noted, colloquium are held fridays 4. Indeed, the focus on how individuals and groups on the ground rather than their political and. Postcolonial literature comes from britains former colonies in the caribbean, africa and india. Vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital george steinmetz forthcoming in journal of world system research 2014 postcolonial theory and the spectre of capital is an important book on a topic of major importance for all of the human and social sciences. Postcolonialism is the academic study of the cultural legacy of colonialism and imperialism, focusing on the human consequences of the control and exploitation of colonized people and their lands.
It is also a school of thought popular because of its rejection of the supposedly universalizing categories of the enlightenment. Pdf a critique of vivek chibbers postcolonial theory. One can posit phases in postcolonial theory, moving across time from the postwar reaction against colonial rule in the fifties and the sixties, albert memmi 1920, aime cesaire 192008, and frantz fanon 19251962, to name a few writers, the shift towards an analysis of culture through the lens of. A model of rigorous reasoning, chibber slogs through the obscurantism of the subaltern school, distilling. Postcolonial theory and the specter of capital by vivek chibber, 9781844679775, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. His book, postcolonial theory and the specter of capital, was published by verso in 20.
On the articulation of marxist and nonmarxist theory in colonial historiography. Developing on aijaz ahmad s earlier critique of saids orientalism 57 and sumit sarkars critique of the subaltern studies scholars. Gayatri chakravorty spivak i have plans to get around to vivek chibbers postcolonial theory and the specter of capital at some point as well as ranajit guhas dominance without hegemony, one of chibbers chief targets. Project muse postcolonial theory and the specter of capital. She shows how post colonial theory forces us to reconsider some of our founding ideas, reorient our frames of enquiry, and rethink the very notion of colonialism. More specifically still, it is devoted to criticizing the views of three subaltern studies scholars.
1435 914 707 1026 887 1164 1043 333 697 1385 501 156 1365 273 1555 403 443 1269 945 874 15 1502 1259 1248 513 1268 92 801 1168 1298 612 635 752 509 105 323 869 636 1180 477